Building Local Capacity to Respond to Environmental Change: Lessons and Case Studies from New York State

CaRDI Reports Issue 1

The utility and limitations of the New Ecological Paradigm scale for children

The New Ecological Paradigm (NEP) scale adapted for use with children (NEP-C) is one of the most frequently used measures of children’s environmental beliefs. Though widely utilized, the limitations of the NEP-C instrument are often overlooked. Based on a systematic synthesis of existing literature examining the NEP-C, we argue that the scale assesses specific types of beliefs within the larger NEP, that some children have difficulty comprehending items of this scale, and that the one-factor and three-factor models proposed in the original NEP-C did not achieve an exact fit to empirical data. Additionally, the relevance of the NEP-C total score as a predictor of children’s pro-environmental behaviors is questionable. Although the NEP-C is useful for measuring specific types of environmental beliefs, many researchers using this scale may be interested in broader constructs. We highlight potential benefits and drawbacks of using the NEP-C and discuss new directions for environmental education research

Visitor Attitudes Toward and Support for Invasive Species Management at Cumberland Island National Seashore

Abstract Controlling invasive species has become a management priority on public lands across America. Although managers recognize the need for policies that minimize the impact of non-indigenous organisms, the extent to which the public supports these policies remains largely unknown. This study used an on-site intercept survey of visitors to Cumberland Island National Seashore, GA, (N = 1,166) to assess public attitudes toward invasive species. Based on responses, visitors were grouped into two main attitude categories: absolute ecocentric individuals (who believed all living things had a right to coexist) and adaptive ecocentric individuals (who acknowledged that some degree of control may be necessary to restore ecosystem integrity). Despite conflicting perspectives, members of both groups agreed that adaptive on-site management was the most acceptable and least controversial method of invasive species control. Future studies could build on this approach to identify stakeholder characteristics that help to predict invasive species management preferences

Visitors’ Climate Change Beliefs & Perceptions of Climate-Sensitive Resources at Great Sand Dunes National Park

Abstract Ecological consequences associated with climate change are becoming increasingly noticeable in nature-based recreation areas. Research is therefore needed to better understand nature-based recreationists’ perceptions of, attitudes towards, and behavioral responses to climate change and resource impacts in parks. This study explored strategies for assessing and responding to visitor perceptions of climate change at Great Sand Dunes National Park (GRSA), Colorado. In the summer of 2011, researchers intercepted visitors at GRSD and invited them to complete an online questionnaire. Visitors reported strong beliefs that global climate change was currently happening, but less certainty regarding the belief that human activities are influencing climate. Studies such as this may provide information for interpreters and park staff regarding climate change, and increase visitors’ understanding of climate change. Future research could expand upon this exploratory study in an effort to inform resource management decisions and develop targeted climate change visitor education programs

Place Attachment and Willingness to Pay: How Do Visitors Value State Parks?

Abstract State parks provide benefits for members of the public who may not have access to natural environments. In this context, it is critical to understand how minority groups value and depend on state parks. To better understand these issues research was conducted during the summers of 2009 and 2010 at three state parks in north Georgia. Intercept surveys were administered to 929 state park visitors. Data pertaining to whether or not visitors perceived themselves as being dependent on state parks and were willing to pay for parks were collected. Results of an exploratory factor analysis suggested that place dependency varied by race/ethnicity, education and income. Results revealed a positive relationship between willingness to pay and place dependency. Results of this study may provide Georgia state park managers with a better understanding of how visitors, in particular minorities, value state parks

Four challenges for measurement in environmental psychology, and how to address them

Stress and Psychopatholog

Children\u27s Time Outdoors: Results from a National Survey

Abstract In the past decade, much has been said and written about American children’s declining outdoor leisure time. These claims are confounded by the absence of a baseline for detecting trends in children’s activities and time spent outdoors. The USDA Forest Service initiated a general population telephone survey, the National Kids Survey, to address this issue. This paper summarizes data collected during the first phase of this project (2007-2009). Results suggest that most children across all demographic groups are spending a substantial amount of time outdoors daily. Interaction with the natural environment varies as playing/hanging out, physical activities, and technology-centered activities appear to be more popular than nature-based activities. Future research efforts should build on these initial data and continue to monitor children’s outdoor activities patterns across diverse populations

Using art to assess environmental education outcomes

Construction of developmentally appropriate tools for assessing the environmental attitudes and awareness of young learners has proven to be challenging. Art-based assessments that encourage creativity and accommodate different modes of expression may be a particularly useful complement to conventional tools (e.g. surveys), but their efficacy and feasibility across diverse contexts has not been adequately explored. To examine the potential utility of integrating art into evaluations of environmental education outcomes, we adapted an existing drawing prompt and corresponding grading rubric to assess the environmental attitudes and awareness of children (ages 6–12) at summer camps in Athens, GA, USA (n = 285). We then compared children’s drawings with scores on a more typical survey instrument that measured similar outcomes, the Children Environmental Perception’s Scale. Results showed that a drawing prompt was a practical and unique learner-centered tool for measuring distinct components of environmental attitudes and awareness. Findings also revealed different response patterns across the two instruments, highlighting the value of using multiple approaches (e.g. art-based and survey-based) to assess cognitive and affective aspects of children’s environmental orientations

Tourists’ motivations, learning, and trip satisfaction facilitate pro-environmental outcomes of the Antarctic tourist experience

Tourism in Antarctica has been growing and diversifying. While Antarctic tourists are purported to have meaningful interactions with the Antarctic environment, little empirical research exists to understand how motivations and trip characteristics of the Antarctic journey shape tourists' experiential outputs, which may in turn influence their pro-environmental outcomes. To examine these relationships, we conducted exploratory analyses using 242 pre-and post-trip surveys collected during the 2019–2020 Antarctic season. We identified four motivation types of Antarctic tourists: experience & learning, adventure into Antarctica, social bonding, and trip of a lifetime. Following the interactional model of tourist experience, we associated this motivation typology and trip characteristics with experiential outputs (Perceived Learning, Measured Learning, and Satisfaction) and pro-environmental outcomes (Environmental Concerns, Management Preferences, and Behavior Intentions). Our results indicated most tourists traveling to Antarctica already possessed high levels of pro-environmental attitudes and behavior intentions, leading to few significant changes after the journey. However, we found that the specific inputs of motivations and trip characteristics influenced experiential outputs in different ways -especially Perceived Learning and Satisfaction-, which were strongly associated with pro-environmental outcomes. Findings reinforce the importance of meaningful and transformative Antarctic tourist experiences in promoting sustainable human-environment interactions and provide new insights regarding tourists’ learning and experiential outcomes. Management implications: Tourists traveling to Antarctica hold a diversity of expectations and motivations. These motivations interact with trip characteristics to influence tourists’ experiences. Enhanced understanding of these relationships could contribute to the Antarctic tourism industry efforts to develop strategic promotion, programming, and communication strategies that produce meaningful experiences and foster pro-environmental outcomes. As tourism diversifies, we should reflect on how the Antarctic tourist experience could become more customized and participatory, effectively inspiring Antarctic tourists to serve as stewards and ambassadors for the Last Frontie

Visitor Support for Recreation Fees in Georgia State Parks

Abstract Public land managers are experiencing increasing pressure to create parks that are self-sustaining. Recreation fees can help managers achieve this goal, but tradeoffs associated with fees often produce undesired consequences (i.e., declining visitation) that warrant further investigation. This study used intercept surveys (n = 1049) to examine support for recreation fees among visitors to Georgia state parks. Participants were evenly split regarding their willingness to pay to enter state parks, with a mean willing to pay increase about $2 above the current$5 parking fee. Proposed fee increases negatively affected projected visitation among all groups, particularly low-income visitors. Place attachment ratings were the strongest predictor of support for fees. Results suggest that, to accommodate a diverse clientele, managers could work on strengthening visitors’ attachment to and reliance upon state parks while developing flexible pricing schemes that appeal to a range of potential users